Peanut Butter Cookies

2017 Update: Due to a problem with Photobucket, see here, there will be a lot of recipes without photos. I will be slowly redoing the recipe pages, as best I can, but many other posts will be impossible to replace. I’m doing this in my own time, while continuing to update the blog with new recipes and posts. If you’d like to donate, any amount appreciated, you can do so here. The site will always be free, the recipes will never be locked behind a paywall, but this is a lot of additional work. I’m not demanding or begging, just putting it there so if you feel like repaying my hard work you have that option. I don’t make any money from the site, all that I do here is to help others, I couldn’t charge for that.


A bit of fun with Buttercream and Carob.

Giant Thumbprint Cookie.

Messing around with carob.

 These have been with me from the start you can’t imagine the wonder of tasting a cookie when you thought you’d never see one again. They’ve been tweaked a lot over the years and have reached a point where I feel the base recipe is perfect as is (Humble, ain’t I?) and as you can see I’ve instead focused on trying new varieties with different egg substitutes.


175g Natural Peanut Butter
1 Large Egg
60g Sugar/Light Muscovado Sugar
Dash Vanilla Extract
1/4 Tsp Baking Soda

Makes 15 Cookies or 6 50g Cookies.


1. Preheat oven to 175c (Fan).

2. Combine Eggs, Vanilla Extract and Sugar in a jug and mix well.

3. Put Peanut Butter into bowl, add wet ingredients and Baking Soda and mix, with an electric mixer, until a thick clingy dough has been formed.

4. Form into 1 Tbsp sized balls and flatten onto Greaseproof Paper and bake for 10 minutes. Then remove from Oven and rest on tray for a further 10 minutes. Then let cool completely on a wire-rack.


Sweet Potato Egg: Replace Egg with 70g Mashed Sweet Potato (Either bake or microwave) and just add everything to a bowl and use Light Brown Sugar and mix together. Roll in Cinnamon Sugar just before flattening onto baking sheet. Cookies will be very soft when baked, but will firm up as they cool.

Yoghurt Egg: Replace Egg with 70g Yoghurt and just add everything to a bowl and mix together. Bake the same.

Avocado Egg: Replace Egg with 1/4 Cup mashed Avocado and just add everything to a bowl and mix together. Bake the same.

Banana Egg: Replace Egg with 1/2 ripe mashed Banana and just add everything to a bowl and mix together. Bake the same, cookies will be darker.

Banana Bread: Add 1 Ripe Banana, Mashed and replace Sugar with Brown Sugar. Batter will be softer so smooth with a wet spoon and chill in the fridge for 5 minutes before baking.

No Added Sugar: Replace Sugar with same weight in mashed banana. Add two Tsp Gingerbread Spice or Cinnamon. To prepare wet hands and scoop up 1 Tbsp of of the dough, it will be soft and somewhat sticky, form into a ball, place onto the tray and press down gently. Bake as normal.

Gingerbread with Treacle Buttercream: Use Dark Muscavado Sugar and add the following:

For the Spice: (Or 4 Tsp Gingerbread Spice Blend)

1 Tsp Ground Ginger
1 Tsp Cinnamon
1 Tsp Ground Allspice
1/2 Tsp Ground Nutmeg
1/2 Tsp Ground Cloves
Pinch Black Pepper

For The Buttercream: Use 100g (I used 150g and 37g Butter, it was too much) and 25g Butter, 1/2 Tbsp/15g Treacle and a dash of vanilla extract. Mix as per recipe)

Pumpkin Spice: Use Light Muscovado Sugar, Replace the Egg with 70g Steamed Pumpkin or Squash and add 1 Tsp Pumpkin Spice. Bake as normal.


29 thoughts on “Peanut Butter Cookies

  1. Pingback: Blueberries and Peanut Butter? Ewww…Oh, my word that’s good. | Pep's Free From Kitchen

  2. Pingback: You say Cilantro… |

  3. Pingback: Buckwheat Flour Peanut Butter Biscuits |

  4. Pingback: Yoghurt Egg Buckwheat Tortillas |

  5. Pingback: This Post Contains all of your Recommended Daily Updates |

  6. Pingback: Buckwheat Flour Scones |

  7. Pingback: Chia for Flax? Nope, but There’s Still Hope |

  8. Pingback: Egg Replacement in Gluten Free Cooking – Guest post | Cooking Without Gluten

  9. Pingback: Замена Яиц в Еде без Глютена — Практический Обзор | Готовим Без Глютена

  10. Pingback: Cake Decorating and Those Bygone Wheaty Days |

  11. Pingback: Hazelnut Butter |

  12. Pingback: Clusters of Diversity |

  13. Pingback: Freak Winds and Peanut Butter Gingerbread Cookies |

  14. Pingback: Sunflower Seed Butter Cookies |

  15. Pingback: Pumpkin Seed Butter Cookies |

  16. Pingback: Almond Butter |

  17. Pingback: Cinnamon and Dang Rad Grampa |

  18. Pingback: Brazil Nut Butter |

  19. Pingback: Strange Weather in Ireland |

  20. Pingback: Banana Curd |

  21. Pingback: Vegetable Medley Pasta Sauces | Pep's Free From Kitchen

  22. Pingback: Giant Peanut Butter Thumbprint Cookie Tutorial | Pep's Free From Kitchen

  23. My, what kind of chickens do you raise in Ireland? The Fionn mac Cumhaill breed? Or is it that organically raised French chickens are just lazy? Anyway, I had to change the amounts of peanut butter and sugar to respect the proportions ( x 0.9 )
    This was the weirdest and fastest cookie dough I ever made. Other than the changes I just mentioned, I followed the recipe to the letter. Fellow dear readers, you can trust Jack on this one (as on many others): I have just had a cookie from the cooling rack, it is really good!
    Now this is the sort of recipe you can whip up for unexpected guests within half an hour, provided you keep all-natural peanut butter at hand. Perfect!

    Liked by 1 person

    • They’re from a woman who raises them herself. They must be fed better than any chicken in Ireland as the yolks are a vibrant yellow. There have been some nearer one hundred grams. The only problem is when you taste eggs that delicious then store bought ones pale in comparison. It’s an odd dough that’s for sure. I still marvel at it turning from a wet mess to a firm, pliable dough in the wink of an eye. I’m really glad that it not only worked for you, but that you enjoyed it. The natural peanut butter is a must, I keep a tub on hand at all times for baking and cooking.

      Liked by 1 person

  24. Pingback: the fastest, easiest, without much sugar, gluten-free peanut butter cookies: Jack’s recipe (foolproof) – sulfite-free cooking

  25. Pingback: Sayonara Squash | Pep's Free From Kitchen

  26. Pingback: Counting The Days Until The Rest Of My Life | Pep's Free From Kitchen

  27. Pingback: Magnetic Blooms | Pep's Free From Kitchen

  28. Pingback: No Added Sugar Peanut Butter Cookies | Pep's Free From Kitchen

Comments are closed.